Forest Whitaker & Fozzie Bear

Samantha Steele & Kristen Johnson

Brad Childress & Mr. Noodle's Brother, Mr. Noodle

Chauncey Billups & P Diddy

from John Salley

Chad Pennington & Lionel Messi

"We look like Cartoon characters!" 

Daryl Hall & Kevin Connolly

Donald Faison & Sean May

Eli Manning Special

TJ Kidd & The Great Gazoo

from Guy Torry

Odette Annable & Janice Dickinson

Just to be clear, Janice is one of the top 4 or 5 prettiest dark-eyed girls of all time.
Odette, uh, has hazel eyes.

Evolutionary Special

Kenny Chesney & Stephen Anthony Lawrence

Robin Williams & Dale Hunter

Ian Somerhalder & Chris Pine

Christine Baransky & Sandra Bullock

Todd Haley & Sacha Baron Cohen

from @mookiewilson86

Todd somehow manages to look more like Borat than Sacha does

Mark Consuelos & Mark Sanchez

Todd Marinovich & Ron Howard

Katrina Bowden = Christine Taylor + Thandie Newton

Tripleganger Special

Daniel Day-Lewis & Anson Mount

Iggy Pop & Stuart

The soul of a liar is black like poop

Ralph Garman & John Henson

Michael Roof (Chicken) & Clint Howard

Harland Williams = Jorge Posada & Mayhem Miller

Tripleganger Special

the length                                                                                 the demeanor

Ron Jeremy = Scotty Too Hotty + Khalid Sheikh Mohammed

Tripleganger Special

the boyish charm & cobalt eyes                                                     the filthy stank

Nick Thune & Adam Scott

January Jones & Michele Bachmann

Emperor Palpatine Special